home pageNews Viewpoints Spirituality Liturgy Entertainment Calendar Sports
Google
at google.com
at the-tidings.com
THIS WEEK'S
HIGHLIGHTS
News
Faith-based groups look for unified fight against effects of HIV
Extended PEPFAR promises billions for global HIV/AIDS care
Marriage initiative becomes monetary battleground
Millions of immigrant stories later, CLINIC celebrates 20 years
Upcoming conventions, pay cuts may hasten overdue budget
'One Body, One Spirit': NPM in L.A.
Obituaries
bullet History was --- and is --- here
bullet California State Historical Landmarks
bullet Young Ladies Institute celebrates service, history in Ventura
bullet Local Catholic HS grads lead USA Softball in Beijing

Viewpoints
bullet Humanae Vitae at 40
The Church is holy
Liturgy
bullet Listen closely --- really closely
Spirituality
bullet Prophecy: Challenge and comfort
shim
Entertainment
shim Books: Questions and answers; horrors and heartbreak
shim Movie Reviews
Sports
CYO promotes PLC 'sports as ministry' program

 

 

 


Friday, July 22, 2005
'Charlie' is hugely inventive

USCCB Film & Broadcasting Office
text only version

No, this isn't some tired rehash of the 1971 cult favorite "Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory," but Tim Burton's hugely inventive rethinking of writer Roald Dahl's original work.

Entertaining and stylish, "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory" (Warner Bros.) reverts to the 1964 book's title, putting the emphasis on the central child of the story, sweet-natured young Charlie Bucket, played by Freddie Highmore. You may recall how good he was in "Finding Neverland," particularly in the touching final bench scene with Johnny Depp, who here stars as Willy Wonka, the eccentric candy-maker.

The impoverished Charlie, who lives with his parents (his dad's been laid off from the toothpaste factory) and grandparents in cozy squalor, longs to be one of the five winners who will spend a magical day at the mysterious emporium, run by the reclusive Wonka.

Charlie's grandfather Joe (David Kelly), in fact, once worked for Wonka, who, after some dishonest employees began stealing his secret recipes, decided to dispense with all the locals, and hire natives from far-off Loompaland instead.

Four totally obnoxious children win the prize tickets hidden in chocolate bars: a grossly overweight boy from Germany (Philip Wiegratz); a spoiled-rotten English girl (Julia Winter); a fiercely ambitious karate-proficient, gum-chewing Southern tyke (AnnaSophia Robb); and a mean-spirited video-game addict (Jordan Fry). Each chaperoned by one adult, they come to the factory on the appointed day.

And so does Charlie who wins the last ticket when he finds money in the street and is able to buy a chocolate bar --- after, courtesy of his family's limited income, his first two attempts to buy one fail. He brings his dotty grandfather along.

At the factory, they're met by Wonka, a pale-faced, longhaired man-boy with "issues," chiefly generated by memories of his autocratic dentist father (Christopher Lee), who deprived him of sweets as a child.

As the children and the parents are guided by Wonka through the Oz-like wonders of the factory, each child reveals his or her selfish nature, and meets the (nonfatal) fate they deserve, each comeuppance accompanied by a musical number, lyrics by the late Dahl. Thus, the fat boy falls into a lake of melted chocolate; the blond overachiever insists on chewing the newly invented gum that gives the sensation of eating a full meal, and blows up to gigantic proportions; the spoiled girl demands a pet squirrel when she sees Wonka's battery of walnut-cracking critters, who drag her to the trash-heap chute; and the video nerd puts himself in a particle-transporting machine, and emerges a pint-size version of his former self.

All of these are treated comically, and are not as gruesome as they sound on paper, though some youngsters might have a problem with the attacking squirrels.

The Oompa-Loompa workers are all played by the actor named Deep Roy, digitized into legions, whose omnipresent face becomes a bit tiresome after a while.

Some of the choreography is pretty funny, including a Busby Berkeley homage, Oompa-Loompa-style. The contemporary-sounding music is quite different than "The Candy Man" and other bouncy Anthony Newley-Leslie Bricusse songs heard in the last go-round.

Overall, director Burton's take on the Dahl tale is predictably darker than the last version, and combines Dickensian atmospherics (though the setting is contemporary) with mordant wit. Danny Elfman's pounding and ominous score of the credits signals the different tone of the remake.

There are many memorable sequences, such as Wonka's elaborate chocolate palace built for an Indian prince that melts during the hot weather. There are subtle and obvious riffs on everything from the saccharine Disney "Small World" exhibit to Munchkinland to, most brilliantly, a hilarious takeoff on Kubrick's "2001: A Space Odyssey."

Quite unlike 1971's Gene Wilder, the remarkable Depp gives an understated, slyly droll performance and seems, at times, to be sending up Michael Jackson's Neverland persona. But all the actors are first-rate, including Helena Bonham Carter and Noah Taylor as Charlie's mom and dad, and the other kids' parents (James Fox, Missi Pyle and Adam Godley among them). Geoffrey Holder provides the wooly narration.

The film contains positive messages about family, loyalty, unselfishness, and only a few scenes of tongue-in-cheek peril that might upset the very youngest viewers. The USCCB Office for Film & Broadcasting classification is A-I -- general patronage. The Motion Picture Association of America rating is PG -- parental guidance suggested.

-- Harry Forbes

Wedding Crashers

Male comedy teams have long been a staple in Hollywood. Just think of Hope and Crosby, Abbott and Costello or Lewis and Martin. Now comes Vince Vaughn and Owen Wilson, who play lifelong friends with a peculiar hobby in the unnecessarily raunchy farce "Wedding Crashers" (New Line).

Hope and Crosby they're not, but they work well together, injecting a rascally levity into a summer playing field dominated by brooding Batmen and menacing Martians.

Unfortunately, director David Dobkin chooses to pander to the lowest common denominator --- rather than trusting his leads' considerable comic competence (and chemistry) --- mucking up what could have been a smart screwball buddy film with lewd sight gags and foul language.

As the title suggests, the two play divorce mediators --- sensitive straight man John (Wilson) and roguish goofball Jeremy (Vaughn) --- whose real passion is infiltrating weddings (the more difficult the better). They do it partly for the challenge, partly for the food, but mostly to seduce as many romantically predisposed women as possible (a goal depicted through a risque montage).

They learned their scam from a "legendary" shyster named Chaz (played in a brief cameo by an unbilled Will Ferrell) and are bound by its strict rules. An amusing sequence shows the chameleonlike duo blending into different ethnic settings, including Jewish, Irish, Italian and even Chinese.

The ultimate test comes when they crash the high-profile wedding of the daughter of Washington bigwig William Cleary (Christopher Walken). Having successfully conned their way into the beltway bash, they quickly make moves on Cleary's two other daughters --- both bridesmaids --- Claire (Rachel McAdams) and her slightly psychotic sister Gloria (Isla Fisher). In an uncharacteristically vampish turn, Jane Seymour plays Cleary's unfaithful wife.

Things go awry when John falls for Claire and --- bending the rules --- convinces Jeremy to accept Gloria's invitation to spend an extended weekend with the dysfunctional Cleary clan at their Kennedylike compound, so John can woo Claire away from her undeserving and ultracompetitive Ivy League fiance (pompously played by Bradley Cooper).

Vaughn and Wilson manage to make the caddish characters appealing, despite their dishonorable behavior. Some of the interplay is quite funny, making the film's overall crassness all the more a pity.

The fact that they are likable hardly justifies the movie's uncalled-for ribaldry that makes light of casual sex and promiscuity, including a dinner scene where Gloria fondles Jeremy under the table, and a racy bedroom sequence involving Jeremy, Gloria and (later) her gay brother (Keir O'Donnell).

Though John and Jeremy do come to regret their dishonesty and sincerely realize the emptiness of their lifestyle, give me Hope and Crosby any day.

The film contains much crude sexual humor and situations, some involving partial nudity; a brief irreverent comment; and pervasive rough and vulgar language and profanity. The USCCB Office for Film & Broadcasting classification is O (morally offensive). The Motion Picture Association of America rating is R (restricted).

--- David DiCerto

Harry Forbes is director and David DiCerto is on the staff of the Office for Film & Broadcasting of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops.



copyright The Tidings Corporation ©2004
Contact us at: info@the-tidings.com




give us your comments




past issues