home pageNews Viewpoints Spirituality Liturgy Entertainment Calendar Sports
Google
at google.com
at the-tidings.com
THIS WEEK'S
HIGHLIGHTS
News
Fire leaves thousands homeless in four counties
After the fire: How you can help
Downturn brings call to extend unemployment benefits
Attorney General: Let Prop. 8 take effect while lawsuits are reviewed
'This is a special time. There's no excuses.'
Despite poor economy, Adopt-A-Family giving spirit is strong
Young people want religion, say conference speakers
Helping each other on the journey
St. Brendan Church: A history
'Building Solidarity': 33 receive Justice and Peace Awards
Justice and Peace Honors
St. Margaret's Center moves to meet rising needs
Project THINK: 'Bringing hope to homework'
Guadalupe Torch relay begins

Viewpoints
The 2008 Presidential Election
The two Americas
Liturgy
'Whatever you did for the least …'
Spirituality
A Spiritual Reflection on the Current Difficult Economic Times
Ad usam
Learning thankfulness the hard way
shim
Entertainment
Movies Review
Sports
CYO promotes PLC 'sports as ministry' program

 

 

 


Friday, August 20, 2004
Movie Reviews

text only version

'Princess Diaries 2': Sweet but schmaltzy
Once upon a time, director Garry Marshall set out to make a sequel to his mildly charming 2001 romantic teen comedy, "The Princess Diaries."

And so a decree went out to all the girl-power cliches in the land, summoning them to his script, the result being the sweet but schmaltzy "The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement" (Disney).

For those who missed the first film, Anne Hathaway plays Mia, a nerdy American teenager who learned that she is next in line for the throne of Genovia, a Monaco-like realm somewhere in Europe whose national anthem sounds surprisingly similar to that of Freedonia's in the Marx Brothers' "Duck Soup."

In the original, Mia -- under the tutelage of her regal grandmother, Queen Clarisse (Julie Andrews) -- was transformed from the proverbial ugly duckling into a graceful royal swan.

Now five years and one Princeton degree later, Mia is turning 21 and, with her grandma stepping down, is ready to assume her role as ruler of Genovia. But there is one major speed bump on the way to the castle: Genovian law forbids an unmarried woman to be crowned queen; the same stricture does not apply to male heirs.

Faced with the coronation conundrum, Genovia's parliament is left with two options: Either Mia finds a suitable monarchical mate in 30 days, or the crown passes to her royal rival, Lord Nicholas Devereaux (Chris Pine), a dashing homegrown prince whose claim is championed by his Machiavellian uncle (John Rhys-Davies).

In the quest for a groom, it is arranged for Mia to marry Lord Andrew Jacoby (Callum Blue), a handsome young British blueblood. The only problem is she finds herself falling for Devereaux.

Will Mia choose true love or duty? Or, will she have her royal wedding cake and eat it too?

As in the first "Diaries," the mediocre material is elevated somewhat by the buoyant and beautiful Hathaway, whose sunny smile could light up a small kingdom or two. As always, Andrews adds a touch of elegance to an otherwise graceless and clumsy affair. Also returning are Heather Matarazzo as Mia's old high school gal-pal, Lilly, and Hector Elizondo as Queen Clarisse's head of security.

At least the original film had a cute Pygmalion premise with Andrews playing Prof. Higgins to Hathaway's goofy Eliza Doolittle. This time around, the derivative humor is spread thin and much more forced. The film also lacks the freshness of the first installment, a common malady among sequels -- unless, of course, the protagonist is a green ogre, spins webs or has the surname Corleone.

Pre-pubescent princess-wannabes will undoubtedly find the Cinderella-like ball gowns and tiaras enchanting, but older viewers may find themselves pulling a Sleeping Beauty for much of the film.

"The Princess Diaries 2" is the most recent example of an emerging subgenre, the feminist fairy tale. Along with other recent wish-fulfillment fantasies like "The Prince & Me" and "Ella Enchanted" (which also starred Hathaway), "Diaries 2" freights the traditional storybook formula with preachy dollops of gender politics pap.

With Hollywood serving up a steady stream of toxically violent and hypersexualized fare, you would think that it would be easy to give a G-rated film -- with recognizable stars, glossy production values and a name director -- an enthusiastic thumbs-up. Sadly, that is not the case. Still, in this day and age, Marshall deserves credit for making a movie that eschews "edginess" in favor of a more wholesome tone and has a positive, family-friendly message.

For that reason alone, this is one "Engagement" you may want to keep.

In spite of some thematic elements and a few brief kissing scenes, the USCCB Office for Film & Broadcasting classification is A-I -- general patronage. The Motion Picture Association of America rating is G -- general audiences, all ages admitted.

-- David DiCerto

David DiCerto is on the staff of the Office for Film & Broadcasting of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops.

Danny Deckchair (Lions Gate)
Delightful Australian comedy/fantasy about a cement worker who, bored with his job and disillusioned with his opportunistic -- and unfaithful -- girlfriend, attaches giant helium balloons to a patio chair at a family barbecue and is carried far away, eventually crash-landing in another town where he falls in love and wins the affection of the townsfolk. Writer/director Jeff Balsmeyer's first feature-length film is a heartwarming, refreshingly wholesome and uplifting fable about possibility and overcoming one's imagined limitations. Implied sexual situations. (A-III, PG-13)

A Home at the End of the World (Warner Independent Pictures)
Bland adaptation of Michael Cunningham's novel about an unconventional triangular romance about a bisexual (Colin Farrell) who is in love with both his gay best friend (Dallas Roberts) and their bohemian female roommate (Robin Wright Penn). Directed by Michael Mayer and laced with homoerotic images, the tenderly told film explores the human heart's need for love; however, in doing so, it promotes a radical re-defining of traditional ideas concerning family and sexuality. An ambiguous view of human sexuality, including a sympathetic portrayal of homosexual and bisexual relationships, several sexual encounters with nudity, recurring drug content involving minors, a few instances of same-sex kissing, as well as much rough and crude language. (O, R)

Stander (Newmarket)
True-life drama set in 1970s South Africa about white police captain Andre Stander (Thomas Lane), deeply disillusioned by the dehumanizing injustices of apartheid, who, along with two accomplices, bucks the racist system he had spent his life enforcing by pulling off a series of increasingly audacious bank robberies, which he rationalizes as a form of civil disobedience. In spite of a dynamic performance by Lane, director Bronwen Hughes walks a dangerous line between painting a complex portrait of moral outrage and romanticizing Stander's criminal spree as a legitimate form of political protest. Recurring violence, including an intense riot sequence, a few sexual encounters, some nudity, as well as rough and crude language. (L, R)

We Don't Live Here Anymore (Warner Independent)
Dour but grimly absorbing story of two unhappily married couples living in a university town who end up having affairs with each other's spouses. Though told with compassion and perception, astutely scripted, and superbly acted by Mark Ruffalo, Laura Dern, Peter Krause and Naomi Watts, the film is almost unrelievedly downbeat. Much rough and crude language including profanity, intense sexual encounters, and an unconventional view of marriage and adultery. (L, R)

Yu-Gi-Oh! The Movie (Warner Bros.)
Incoherent animated action adventure about a teenager named Yugi (voiced by Dan Green), whose invincible alter ego -- an Egyptian pharaoh whose spirit he channels through a mystical amulet he wears around his neck -- faces off against an ancient evil demon in a high-stakes card duel, with the fate of the world hanging in the balance. Based on the Japanese comic book and trading-card phenomenon, this dizzying and disjointed mess is little more than a 90-minute commercial for "Yu-Gi-Oh!" products. Animated violence and some scary images. (A-II, PG)



copyright The Tidings Corporation ©2004
Contact us at: info@the-tidings.com




give us your comments




past issues