|
The following are movie revies of 'The Alamo' and "I'm Not
Scared."
'The
Alamo'
Set in 1836, "The Alamo" (Disney) tells the dramatic story
of the 200 men whose valiant last stand against overwhelming
odds rallied the cause of Texan independence from Mexico and
changed the course of American history.
While the lone-star legend has already been immortalized
countless times on screen (including a 1960 film starring
John Wayne), most previous versions failed to capture the
complexities of the historical events and personalities involved.
A lifelong student of Alamo lore, Texas-born director John
Lee Hancock refrains from wall-to-wall action and flag-waving
jingoism, in favor of a more character-driven study, which,
despite its epic scale, results in a quite intimate portrait
of unsolicited heroism.
The Alamo itself was founded in 1718 by Spanish monks as
a Franciscan mission in present-day San Antonio. By 1801,
the mission had been converted into military barracks and
renamed after the Spanish cavalry unit stationed there --
the Alamo de Parras. Mexican troops subsequently settled into
the fort around 1821, when Mexico seceded from Spain.
The main action of the movie takes place in February-March
1836, during a time when the political turmoil in Mexico had
reached a boiling point. Texas was still part of Mexico, but
the move to form an independent republic was gaining popularity
among the territory's citizens. A year earlier the newly formed
Texan militia had routed the Mexican army and captured the
Alamo. Grasping the garrison's strategic value, one militia
member states, "As goes the Alamo, so goes Texas."
In a move to crush the rebellion, Mexico's dictator, Gen.
Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna (Emilio Echevarria), personally
leads a massive army to take back the Alamo. Assuming that
Santa Anna would wait out the winter before making his move,
the provisional Texas government mans the fort with only a
small contingent of poorly disciplined conscripts.
Santa
Anna arrives early, catching the Texans off-guard and ill-prepared
for combat. Vastly outnumbered, the defenders -- a mix of
Texians (Anglo settlers) and Tejanos (those of Mexican descent
living in Texas) -- gallantly hold off the superior forces
for 13 days. However, on the morning of March 6, 1836, Santa
Anna's troops storm the fort. The siege becomes a slaughter,
as every Texan is killed in less than 90 minutes.
Rather
than focus solely on the bloody battle, Hancock chooses to
view the siege through the prism of perhaps its three most
famous participants: legendary frontiersman Davy Crockett
(Billy Bob Thornton), demon-driven warrior Jim Bowie (Jason
Patric) and brash, young William Travis (Patrick Wilson),
whose spit-and-polish idealism is challenged when he assumes
command of the ill-fated fort. Each of them arrives at the
Alamo from different paths, but all seek the same thing --
a second chance.
Dennis Quaid plays Sam Houston, the zealous George Washington
of Texas' struggle for independence, the Wellington to Santa
Anna's Napoleon. It is Houston's famous battle cry, "Remember
the Alamo," that rallies the Texan army to victory over Santa
Anna at the Battle of San Jacinto, six weeks after the Alamo
massacre -- a scene that plays rather anticlimactically.
While taking an acceptable amount of dramatic liberty with
history, the film succeeds in conveying the factual -- and,
more importantly, the emotional -- truth of the events depicted.
The characters are not portrayed as cardboard, comic book
heroes, but flesh-and-blood men whose heroism flowed from
less-than-heroic hearts. Hancock does not indulge in cheap
hagiography but shows the characters in all their flawed humanity,
separating man from myth. Bowie is portrayed as a drunkard
and a slave owner. Travis abandoned his wife after years of
serial infidelity.
While falling short of masterpiece status, "The Alamo" is
a stunning piece of muscular moviemaking with its sweeping
scope, panoramic big-sky cinematography, painstaking attention
to historical detail, stirring score and uniformly top-notch
acting -- highlighted by Thornton's show-stealing performance.
The 51-acre reconstruction of the Alamo and surrounding town
of San Antonio de Bexar is billed as the largest free-standing
film set ever built on location in North America.
Hancock's decision to divide viewers' attention among four
protagonists was risky, and could easily have resulted in
a disjointed narrative, but he manages to keep his respective
story lines well-pruned and clearly delineated. And though
some viewers may feel that its glossy veneer at times lends
a romanticizing sheen to the carnage, the movie vividly depicts
the horrors of war.
The
Alamo symbolizes a place where American history meets American
mythology. The reason its story continues to inspire is the
valuable lesson it teaches us: that courage and sacrifice
are at the heart of freedom.
This "Alamo" is worth remembering.
Due to extended, intense battlefield violence and some crude
language, the USCCB Office for Film & Broadcasting classification
is A-III -- adults. The Motion Picture Association of America
rating is PG-13 -- parents are strongly cautioned. Some material
may be inappropriate for children under 13.
Capsule
review of 'I'm Not Scared' (Miramax)
Enthralling thriller about a 10-year-old boy (Giuseppe Cristiano)
living in a remote Sicilian village whose innocence is shattered
when he makes a shocking discovery in an abandoned farmhouse
and learns that the terrible truth behind it leads him closer
to home than he ever would imagine. Masterfully told through
the eyes of a child, director Gabriele Salvatores combines
suspenseful storytelling with hauntingly beautiful visuals
of sprawling, sun-baked Italian vistas to craft an intimate
coming-of-age tale of courage and compassion. Subtitles. Some
violence, recurring rough and crude language. The USCCB Office
for Film & Broadcasting classification is A-III -- adults.
The Motion Picture Association of America rating is R -- restricted.
David DiCerto is on the staff of the Office for Film
& Broadcasting of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops.
|